
Problem 02 · Leadership
“We need a CMO and can’t afford one.”
Marketing needs a senior leader. The budget covers a director, not a K-12 CMO with the experience the job needs. So the company hires the best person it can afford and hopes they grow into the job before the board runs out of patience.
What’s really going on
Most K-12 companies between $2M and $10M can’t afford a K-12 CMO who has done it all, so they hire the best leader they can afford. Often that’s a strong director who is ready for a VP title. We call this the Step-Up Hire. The person is good. The gaps are predictable: how districts actually buy, how marketing connects to sales, and how marketing decisions ripple into forecasting, finance, product, support, and delivery.
One K-12 company I was part of hired the marketing leader it could afford: a director from another company who was ready for a VP role. She was excellent at leading the team and understood every marketing channel the company used. But she had spent her whole career in marketing. She didn’t know the K-12 buying motion deeply, she wasn’t familiar with sales, and she treated lead generation as the North Star without seeing how it connected to sales, forecasting, finance, product development, customer support, delivery, and the rest of the company. We worked to build her skills quickly, and it wasn’t enough on its own. What filled the gap was adding a fractional leader to the team, bringing seasoned K-12 judgment and coaching alongside her.
What most companies try
They hire the most senior person they can afford and hope experience from another industry transfers to K-12. Or they hire the strong director and expect them to grow into the role on the job, with no one to learn from.
Or they hold out for the perfect CMO and leave the seat empty for months while marketing drifts.
What works instead
Decide what the role has to own before you hire.
Write down how marketing should connect to sales, the forecast, and the rest of the company, and what K-12 buying knowledge the person needs on day one. That tells you which gaps you can live with and which you can’t.
Hire for strengths, then fill the gaps on purpose.
If the leader you can afford is strong on channels and team leadership, plan for the K-12 market knowledge and company-level judgment they don’t have yet, instead of hoping they’ll pick it up.
Pair the new leader with senior help.
A fractional CMO working alongside a newly stepped-up leader covers the gaps while that person grows. It’s coaching and leadership at the same time, without a second full-time salary.
How you’ll know it’s working
The marketing plan ties to pipeline and revenue, not just lead counts. Sales and marketing plan together. Within a few quarters, your leader is making the calls the fractional advisor used to make.
Working with Midday Advisors
Midday Advisors works two ways here: defining the role and the strategy before you hire, or working alongside the leader you hired as a fractional CMO and coach. Either way, the goal is a marketing leader who can run the function without us.
On the blog: The Case Against Hiring a Full-Time CMO Before You Have a Strategy and K-12 Specialist vs. Generalist Fractional CMO: What Actually Changes
Field guide: What Is a Fractional CMO and Does Your Education Organization Need One?
Frequently Asked Questions
Not before it has a go-to-market strategy. A CMO hired first spends their early months building the strategy the company should have set before the search, and without that strategy it is hard to know which kind of CMO to hire.
A fractional CMO leads marketing part time: sets the strategy, builds the plan, and directs the team or agencies doing the work. For K-12 companies between $2M and $10M in revenue, it often covers the need without the cost of a full-time executive.
When the strategy is set, the marketing plan needs a leader every day, and the company can support the team that leader will need. A fractional CMO can help define the role and screen candidates when that time comes.